Let’s get one thing clear. Dubstep is not popular because it is “good.” But it is popular nonetheless. Popular enough that even Microsoft is utilizing it in commercials to get mass-appeal. I’m not here today to criticize dubstep any more than I’ve done in the past, but rather to analyze what it is that made dubstep so tremendously popular when compared to “edgy” or abrasive subgenres in other types of music (e.g. metal or punk).

I mean, it is rather odd, initially. Dubstep’s fanbase used to be something like the metalheads of electronic music (or the metalcore heads, or however you want to compare). Those people have been completely usurped by the mainstream. That kind of thing never happened to the likes of death metal, underground hip-hop, or old school punk. These genres have a lot in common, though. They’re all unorthodox, noisy, often considered displeasing, and not easy to come by unless you’re looking for them. And to be frank, their fans rarely did anything constructive toward bringing their respective genres to the mainstream. The people I remember listening to dubstep a couple years ago would not be happy that it’s reached Party Rock Anthem status in the meantime. And the people who are new to dubstep these days probably don’t even know who used to like it. In short, I don’t credit the fans for dubstep’s rise.

To be honest, I think dubstep came at the right time, and other genres did not. The most popular electronic genre for potentially the last two decades has been house, and for many years, house has not changed much. By itself, it’s not a genre with much potential, because they figured out what worked back in the 90’s and stuck to it with only a few tweaks as technology improved. In terms of incorporating electronic music into pop, it could be said that house has been there way before the recent trend. The recent trend, however, happened right when dubstep was getting going. It worked perfectly. Modern pop was due for an image change. Electronic music was experiencing a boom around the world. Ordinary electronic music had “been done” before in pop, but something extreme like dubstep was new, and it turned out to work like a charm. Artists like Rihanna were able to feed off dubstep to generate a bad-girl vibe. Had this been 10 years ago, that wouldn’t have been an option.

I’d say this didn’t happen to metal because rock was never in that “place.” We all know that rock has had image changes galore, and I think the fact that rock never found itself constrained to the requirements of pop music (basic, catchy, danceable, fun) prevented there being a vacuum that metal had to fill. That’s not to say that metal didn’t have its impact on rock music – there are plenty of new genres today that exist because of metal; metal didn’t become the new “thing” for rock the way dubstep has taken over electronic music and the pop artists that utilize electronic sounds in their music. With pop, I think a lot of artists/producers found themselves realizing that they had been doing the same thing for too long, and needed a clever way to spice it up without breaking the pop formula. Guys like Skream and Skrillex could not have had better timing.

To me, that explains where mainstream dubstep got its roots. The final question is “why do people that would not normally like abrasive music suddenly like dubstep?” The truth is, they simply didn’t have a choice in the matter. There are a lot of people out there who listen to music because it’s there. That is pop’s market, after all. When Nicki Minaj says she’s going to make a song with dubstep elements, that’s what people are going to listen to. When clubs play this music, that’s what people are going to get used to. After no time at all, it’s the norm, and they like it. Now, we wait to find out what ridiculous sound comes after the time of drops and wobbles. Hell, I’m interested.


4 thoughts on “Why is dubstep popular?

  1. Very interesting article. I agree that dubstep was in the right place at the right time and fortunate to have the EDM Revolution in it tail wind. I also agree with your assertion that rock has never been constrained to the requirements of pop music as this is a major factor in dubsteps mainstream ascension over metal.The pop formula was getting tired and worn out. Typically there has always been a little niche in the pop world for the edgier songs. Its usually been filled by rock but (as you mentioned in your previous article), rock has gone soft. So it makes sense that in an electronic pop world – “electronic punk” was the answer. And I think thats what dubstep is – the punk rock of the electronic world.And I completely agree with you statement about why its popular amongst mainstream crowds – essentially they are sheep and will listen to anything as long as bieber, minaj or gaga is doing it.


  2. As someone who has been following and listening to dubstep for several years now, I can tell you that the scene has been overwhelmed and completely usurped by skrillex wannabes and the music is all starting to sound samey samey. When I first got into it there was alot more variety but now alot of the ‘good’ artists are distancing themselves from the genre – not all to dissimilar to the Deftones and Linkin Park back during the nu-metal days.But the good news (for you at least) is that popularity in the genre has peaked – http://www.google.com/trends/?q=dubstep,+skrillexThis of course refers primarily to the ‘brostep’ fad which has taken hold in recent years. Dubstep as a genre however – is here to stay.Lately I have been listening to alot of future garage and future pop. It would be awesome if you could write an article on that as there have been many recent innovations in the genre. I will post a list of songs as a starting point.


  3. Oh god, I love future garage. I have been thinking of writing about it for a long time now, but there’s too many artists I want to mention. Haven’t actually heard any future pop, though. Sounds scary by name, but I’ll check it out.I wouldn’t count on brostep going away just yet. I’ve been hearing it on popular TV shows, in ads, and of course on the radio embedded in other songs.I’m glad you liked this article. Some of the people I know who like dubstep were not big fans of the concept.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s